Herbert's First Halloween

June 26, 2017
A piglet learns what trick-or-treating is all about in this gentle father-son story. “Herbert was not sure about Halloween,” begins Rylant. Herbert’s father attempts to share his love of the holiday, starting with an old photo of himself in a cowboy costume. Herbert remains skeptical, but asks, “Can I be a tiger?” Father and son get to work on the costume and decorations, and Herbert practices his roar for the big night. Henry’s warm domestic scenes bring to mind the pig family at the heart of Jean Van Leeuwen’s Tales of Oliver Pig as Rylant highlights the comfortable bond between parent and child. Wearing a cowboy outfit, Herbert’s father accompanies him for a night of trick-or-treating. With his first Halloween a success, Herbert is already planning next year’s costume. Perhaps he’ll be back for other holiday firsts, too. Ages 2–4. Author’s agent: Steven Malk, Writers House. Illustrator’s agent: Robin Rue, Writers House.

January 1, 2018
In this low-key father-son story, pig youngster Herbert is "not sure about Halloween," but his father loves it. Dad's excitement quickly spreads to son as together they decide on and make Herbert's costume (tiger), carve a pumpkin ("They named it Jack"), and go trick-or-treating. Henry's digital illustrations capture sweet moments of this bonding experience and play up the un-spooky aspects of Halloween.

(Copyright 2018 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)

Starred review from September 1, 2017

Toddler-PreS-Herbert, like many other young children, is just a little bit anxious about his first Halloween. The text is simple yet conversational. The clear but somewhat muted illustrations allow for a slow, thoughtful exploration about this upcoming challenge. Father is very patient, letting Herbert make his own decisions about what he will be and carefully measuring the little one step-by-step for a tiger costume. Herbert's confidence increases as he practices his roar in the closet. As his courage grows, so will that of the children enjoying his story. The pumpkins are carved with happy faces and named Jack, which will help dispel fear of the holiday. The spread depicting the overview of neighborhood children out trick-or-treating is somewhat lit; readers will be able to identify all the costumes. Rylant and Henry know children well and it shows; this book is sure to become a dog-eared favorite. VERDICT This winning introduction to Halloween meets young children where they are, and will be a welcome addition to all libraries. Day care centers and new parents will appreciate it greatly.-Elizabeth Swartz, Warrior Run School District, PA

Copyright 2017 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.